With new laws, pressures on the Court system and the economic reality of escalating legal costs, it is time for arbitration to be considered a serious method of alternative dispute resolution. See the full article by clicking here.
The Oklahoma legislature recently amended the family law code to require courts to conduct a substantive (not proffer) temporary order hearing on child custody, visitation, child support, and other ancillary matters, including property.[1] Where domestic violence is alleged, the same substantive hearing must be held within ten (10) days.[2] The amendment becomes effective November 1, 2024.[3] This will initially cause significant docket congestion in the larger legal communities such as Tulsa and Oklahoma counties. Practitioners can anticipate ‘cattle call’ dockets with hundreds of cases being disposed of with rapid-fire dispensation of the “substantive” hearings to meet this statutory deadline. Arbitration of these temporary order hearings, if embraced by the legal community, could alleviate much of the anticipated chaos. It would give parties the time and expert attention needed to resolve their initial temporary order, if not their entire case, thereby avoiding the madness of an overcrowded docket.
In civil cases, litigation costs have risen every year. Significant expenses are incurred on drawn out discovery disputes, deposition practice and extensive motion contests in litigation. Imagine two parties litigating a dispute under $75,000 paying their attorneys hourly. If fully litigated, the parties may very well spend the amount in controversy on legal fees. According to a 2023 survey by the US Chamber Institute for Legal Reform, the average cost of a civil lawsuit in the US is $135,000. Often, the lawsuit becomes more about the expended fees than the controversy itself. Likewise, it cannot be settled without further litigation. Arbitration can be a less expensive and more efficient alternative to litigation.
THE AVERSIVE MYTHS REGARDING ARBITRATION
Thirty plus years ago, lawyers were reluctant to utilize mediation in attempting settlement of their cases. Anxiety of revealing too much of their best evidence; disclosure of their trial strategy; these were compounded by a potential demonstration of their negotiation weaknesses to the other side. Mediation is now considered mainstream – frequently ordered by courts before pretrial conferences are scheduled; utilized in almost every case; and considered the ‘best hope’ in resolving difficult disputes.
But mediation is not effective in every case for numerous reasons. Parties may not reach compromise; are too dug in on their positions; lawyers and parties have overvalued their case or undervalued their opponent’s position; or parties may simply want their story to be heard by a decision maker. Often, this impasse causes those parties to be the victims of litigation inefficiencies; financial burden of endless discovery disputes; and multiple delays at the courthouse. In these circumstances, Arbitration can be a better option.
Arbitration is a mechanism of settling disputes, and obtaining a final and binding decision, without recourse to a ‘traditional’ court of law. It is a private “quasi-judicial” determination of a dispute, conducted by an independent third party chosen by the parties. Arbitration is a form of alternative dispute resolution in which the parties to a dispute agree to be bound by the decision of the arbitrator they have appointed in a private system of adjudication.
Suggesting arbitration to a trial attorney generally draws a recoiling response. Most lawyers cite the lack of appealability, the expense, lack of rules and legal precedent as reasons not to arbitrate. While there is some legitimate hesitation, much of this anxiety comes from a lack of knowledge about arbitration law and procedure. Here are the myth busters:
Myth Buster 1: Appealability
It is true that many arbitral decisions cannot be appealed on the merits. Given the small number of court judgments which are appealed, many might question what the litigator is really giving up. How many cases are appealed? The numbers are between 11-12% of all cases.[4] And how many of those appeals are successful? In over 92% of appeals, the trial court is affirmed[5]. These numbers worsen when the appeal involves abuse of discretion standards and evidentiary rulings. As such, ‘appealability’ becomes a tradeoff for the client and the lawyer alike. When placed against the benefits of Arbitration’s ability to provide cost efficiency, expedience and closure, reliance upon the small (10% percent) chance of success at appeal, seems like a fallacy of choice.
Myth Buster 2: The Expense
Many arbitral institutions have fast track rules that include the provision of cost capping. Fast Track rules also limit discovery and expedite the hearing to avoid delay and unnecessary financial burdens on the parties. Even though the parties pay the arbitrator fees, they will likely spend far less at arbitration than at litigation.
Myth Buster 3: The Lack of Rules and Precedent
Arbitral institutions and organizations like the American Arbitration Association (AAA), Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services (JAMS), and, locally, The Oklahoma Arbitration Center (OAC) have rules specific to the type of dispute and can be tailored to the needs of the parties. Most have model arbitration clauses and referral orders available on their websites. These allow for the selection of rules and the applicability of law to be used in the proceeding. All of these give similar predictability to the practitioner and party as litigation does.
So Why Arbitration?
The main advantages to arbitration are party autonomy (choice of decision- maker); efficiency; confidentiality; and finality.
Party Autonomy
In arbitration, the parties nominate either the single arbitrator or a panel of arbitrators. In litigation a party is randomly assigned a judge. Judges may have come from a variety of practices such as the District Attorney’s Office or the Public Defender’s Office having little experience in the civil or family courts throughout his or her career. More so now than before, the judge may have an overflowing docket where he or she is overwhelmed and incapable of giving the necessary time needed to a complex case. Arbitrators are generally seasoned practitioners, chosen by the parties for their expertise in the subject matter of the dispute. He or she will dedicate the time necessary to reach a fair and just decision in the case.
Efficiency
Besides the fast-track rules and cost efficiency factors discussed, arbitration can be scoped, to deal with multiple or discrete issues. Imagine a scenario where parties have settled every issue in a divorce or paternity case, but one. The issue at hand is the one ‘non-starter’ for both sides. It is literally the “line in the sand.” Perhaps it is choice of school for children, the value of a family business, parental relocation, or spousal support, to name a few. Instead of compromising the other agreements and litigating the entire case, the parties may agree to the other terms and arbitrate the one issue still in dispute. This avoids months of unnecessary litigation, thousands of dollars in attorney fees, and extended periods of uncertainty for the parties. In this way mediation and arbitration are not mutually exclusive endeavors. Agreements may be made on several issues in mediation and the remaining ones in dispute are then referred to arbitration.
Confidentiality
Arbitral proceedings are confidential, and not for public record. This has multiple advantages. First, company business and trade secrets are protected. Secondly, parties’ sensitive financial information is hidden from public view. Thirdly, the parties’ actions causing the dispute remain private, sparing them the embarrassment of being on oscn.net or pacer. Finally, the arbitral award remains confidential except where a party seeks enforcement in court. All these factors give arbitration a distinct advantage over litigation by maintaining a party’s privacy and preserving their reputation.
Finality
Oklahoma law is very favorable to the confirmation and enforcement of arbitral awards. There are very limited grounds to which an award can by contested under Oklahoma law. These may include a lack of impartiality, corruption, or misconduct by the arbitrator; the arbitrator exceeded his powers under the agreement; a lack of an arbitration agreement or due process violations.[6] It is however important to note, that at litigation before district and appellate courts, the ‘bar’ is set very high to achieve success on these grounds alone.
Summary
Arbitration presents a compelling and timely alternative to traditional litigation, offering party autonomy, efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and confidentiality. As legal costs rise and court dockets become increasingly congested, arbitration provides a practical solution for resolving disputes. By choosing arbitration, parties gain control over the decision-making process, ensuring their cases are handled by experts with the time and focus necessary to reach fair outcomes. As the legal landscape evolves, arbitration stands out as a valuable tool for achieving justice swiftly and privately, making it an option worth serious consideration for both practitioners and their clients
[1] “Caseload Highlights;” The National Center for State Courts; March 2007
[2] Steed, Jason; “Your Chances on Appeal – And How to Improve Them.” The Federal Lawyer; January/February 2016.
[3] See 12 O.S. §1874
[4] “Caseload Highlights;” The National Center for State Courts; March 2007
[5] Steed, Jason; “Your Chances on Appeal – And How to Improve Them.” The Federal Lawyer; January/February 2016.
